Crumbl cookies have exploded in popularity since the bakery’s launch in 2017. These oversized, soft, and incredibly delicious treats have quickly made their way into the hearts (and stomachs) of cookie enthusiasts across the country. But if you’re either looking to save a buck or two or simply don’t have a Crumbl bakery nearby, we’ve got a sweet surprise for you: an impressive collection of over 50 copycat Crumbl cookie recipes for you to try right at home.
Crumbl is famous for rotating 4-5 specialty cookie flavors each week, while their classic chocolate chip cookie remains a constant favorite. In this post, we will explore a wide range of cookie flavors, including both their regular offerings and the ones that make a special appearance only once in a while.
The size and texture of their cookies set CRUMBL apart in the market. Their cookies are generously sized and crafted to perfection, achieving the ideal balance between a slightly crispy exterior and a soft, almost gooey center. The substantial size of the cookies lends a sense of indulgence and makes each bite feel special and satisfying.
CRUMBL masterfully incorporates familiar flavors into their cookies, all the while introducing an unexpected twist. Whether it’s the tang of a Key Lime Pie cookie, the rich decadence of a Chocolate Cupcake Cookie, or the breakfast nostalgia of a Cornbread Cookie, CRUMBL always finds a way to infuse surprise and delight into their creations.
1. Chocolate Cupcake Cookies
Big, soft cookies with that well-loved yellow cake flavor come together with a rich chocolate ganache frosting that’s oh-so-good. This copycat recipe for Crumbl Chocolate Cupcake Cookies is as close as it gets to the real thing! Plus, making these cookies at home means you can have a whole batch ready in less time than it would take you to get to the store and back.
Creating these cookies in your own kitchen isn’t just about the end product. It’s also about the fun of mixing the dough, the smell of cookies baking, and the joy of seeing them cool on the rack. The process is as enjoyable as the result. So, grab your apron, get your ingredients, and let’s start baking these amazing copycat Crumbl cookies!
2. Key Lime Pie Crumbl Cookies
If you’re a fan of Crumbl’s variety, you’ll surely appreciate their Key Lime Pie Cookies. They manage to capture all the zing and creaminess of a classic key lime pie, but cleverly wrapped up in cookie form!
Starting off with hefty balls of cookie dough, you’ll roll them in a crumbled graham cracker mixture. This creates a delectable, slightly crunchy exterior that is the perfect counterpart to the smooth key lime filling.
Next, you’ll shape the dough using a tart tin and a measuring cup. This step forms a little well in the center of each cookie, which is then filled with a creamy, citrusy key lime filling. This mix of tangy and sweet, crunchy and smooth, makes for a cookie that’s an absolute standout. Now, you can create this well-loved Crumbl flavor right in your own kitchen!
3. Circus Animal Cookies
Our next stop in this copycat Crumbl cookie adventure brings us to Circus Animal Cookies, a nostalgic favorite! Their unique pink and white frosting and fun animal shapes take center stage atop these fluffy, dense, and chewy sugar cookies that are dotted with sprinkles.
To really amplify their sweetness, we’ll be using a homemade white chocolate buttercream frosting. This creamy, sweet frosting complements the sugar cookies beautifully and makes each bite even more enjoyable. For an even more authentic Crumbl version, consider topping your cookies with smooth, melted white chocolate. Either way, these Circus Animal Cookies are a treat that’s sure to make your homemade cookie assortment even more special.
4. Soft Snickerdoodle Cookies
Ready for a bit of cinnamon goodness? This Soft Snickerdoodle recipe is exactly what you need. These cookies are not your average size; they’re extra large and super thick, mirroring the generous proportions that Crumbl cookies are known for.
Each cookie is coated in a delicious blend of cinnamon and sugar, which creates a wonderfully aromatic and flavorful outer layer. This sweet, spiced coating is the perfect partner to the soft, chewy interior of the cookie. These snickerdoodles are not just good, they’re fantastic! You’ll be amazed at how close they are to Crumbl’s snickerdoodles.
5. Raspberry Cheesecake Crumbl
If you’re a fan of fruity flavors and creamy textures, these Raspberry Cheesecake Cookies are the next Crumbl copycat recipe you’ll want to try at home. Starting off with a graham cracker-infused cake mix cookie base, these treats already have a wonderful flavor profile. But the real magic happens with the toppings. Each cookie gets a slathering of smooth cheesecake frosting that adds a layer of creamy decadence.
Last but certainly not least, a vibrant raspberry drizzle is added, providing a burst of fresh, tangy flavor. This perfectly complements the rich, creamy frosting and the subtly sweet cookie base. These Raspberry Cheesecake Cookies are indeed a dream come true for Crumbl fans.
6. Cookies and Cream Milkshake
For all the cookies and cream lovers out there, this Crumbl copycat recipe is one you’ll be reaching for time and time again. The Cookies and Cream Cookies are not only incredibly delicious, but they are also super easy to whip up at home, thanks to the convenient start with a simple cake mix.
Every bite of these cookies is packed with the classic cookies and cream flavor that everyone loves. Each cookie is extra soft, making it all too easy to reach for just one more.
7. Turtle Cookies
Imagine biting into a chewy chocolate cookie, its rich cocoa flavor perfectly balanced by the sweetness of gooey caramel. Then, picture that delicious mouthful complemented by the smoothness of melted chocolate and the satisfying crunch of pecans. Sounds like a dream, doesn’t it? This is exactly what this recipe delivers, and it’s sure to impress every cookie love!
8. Sugar Cookie Crumbl
Crumbl is known for its impressively large, chilled sugar cookies, and this recipe captures that perfectly. This isn’t just a standard sugar cookie, though. This copycat recipe brings a buttery richness and a hint of almond flavor to every bite, setting it apart from your regular sugar cookies.
Then, there’s the icing. It’s not just any icing; it’s a vivid pink icing that not only adds a pop of color but also brings an additional layer of sweetness. Some may argue that this icing is the best part of the cookie.
9. Chocolate Caramel Cookies
This is the best Chocolate Caramel Cookie Recipe – perfectly rich and chewy! These cookies are not only delicious but also totally easy to make! With ingredients like chocolate chips, chocolate frosting, and chewy caramels, you simply can’t go wrong.
10. Milk Chocolate Chip Cookies
These cookies are easy to whip up and only require about 10 minutes of prep time. You’ll want to use a stand mixer or electric hand mixer to make these as you won’t get the right consistency if you try to beat them by hand. So if you love a good old fashioned classic this is the recipe for you.
11. Snickerdoodle Cupcake Cookies
Snickerdoodle cupcake cookies are the ultimate treat. They are easy to make and taste just the best snickerdoodle cookie topped with simple cream cheese frosting and a sprinkle of ground cinnamon!
12. Peanut Butter Cup ft. REESE’S
These Crumbl Reese’s cookies are like a big peanut butter party! Imagine a soft peanut butter cookie with big pieces of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups inside. On top, there’s a smooth peanut butter topping with even more Reese’s pieces. If you love peanut butter, you’ll really like these cookies. They’re like peanut butter cookies with a fun twist because of Reese’s cups.
13. Gluten Free Cornbread Cookies
These Gluten Free Cornbread Crumbl Copycat Cookies are full of sweet cornbread flavor. They are topped with honey butter and a honey drizzle. When the bakery released a cornbread cookie earlier in the year, it was super popular. Cookie fans have been raving about it all over the internet. I knew I had to make a gluten free version.
14. Peanut Butter Crumbl Cookies
This Ultimate Crumbl Peanut Butter Cookie Copycat recipe is a perfect knockoff of those huge cookies sold at your local Cumbl Bakery. With peanut butter in three different layers, these super soft & tender cookies are melt-in-your-mouth delicious!
15. Iced Oatmeal Cookies
Soft and chewy Crumbl inspired Iced Oatmeal Cookies. This recipe is so easy and makes the best saucer sized cookies. Bake up a batch of these, they’re only an hour from start to finish.
16. Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies
These are the BEST Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies you can make! They’re thick and chewy, extra chocolatey, and bursting with peanut butter chips. Thanks to a few special ingredients, these extra large cookies bake up gooey in the middle and slightly crisp on the edges – just like a bakery!
17. Old Fashioned Molasses Cookies
Thick chewy Iced Molasses Cookies are going to be your new favorite cookies! Just like grandma used to make, these cookies are pure comfort food! Topped with sweet vanilla icing, you’ll be drooling for more.
18. Ginger Molasses Cookies
These delicious soft ginger molasses cookies are soft and moist! No mixer needed! They’re super thick and amazingly delicious just like straight from the bakery Crumbl treats. Spice hack: use Ginger, ground cinnamon, and cloves– or you can use allspice if you don’t have cloves
19. Double Fudge Chocolate Cookies
When I tell you these cookies are chocolatey, that may be an understatement. Move over double chocolate cookies and triple chocolate cookies, these Death by Chocolate cookies have four types of chocolate in them to give them their next level chocolate cookie goodness. Baking tips: Dark chocolate chips can be substituted with dark chocolate chunks, or semi-sweet chocolate chips or chunks.
20. Fat Red Velvet Cookies
Cake Mix Red Velvet Cookies are simple and tasty sweets you’ll make again and again. These delicious chocolate treats are so easy to make! One of my absolute favorite recipes to make with cake mix. You only need 4 ingredients and 13 minutes of time. Try some French vanilla frosting on top!
21. Churro Cookies
These Crumbl Churro Cookies are like having a churro and a cookie all in one! They’re crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside, and have a yummy cinnamon frosting on top. It’s like a cookie with a fun churro twist!
I don’t know about you but I think these are the absolute best cookie recipes out there. Especially if you love the Crumbl bakery! These copycat treats look so amazing and I can’t wait to make some. I’m eyeballing the Cookies & Cream, which one do you like best? Let us know in the comments or on social!
Leave a Review!